Oversight Hearing – U.S. Department of Homeland Security

DHS Budget and Border OversightHouse Appropriations Subcommittee on Department of Homeland Security · 2025-05-06 · 119th Congress
The House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security held this oversight hearing to review the Department of Homeland Security's fiscal year 2026 priorities in the absence of a full budget request, with Secretary Kristi Noem testifying on border enforcement results, FEMA restructuring, cybersecurity, and the department's reconciliation funding request. Begins at 0:03:34
Transcript
Highlights

Title

DHS FY2026 budget priorities, border security, and FEMA reform

Purpose

The House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security held this oversight hearing to review the Department of Homeland Security's fiscal year 2026 priorities in the absence of a full budget request, with Secretary Kristi Noem testifying on border enforcement results, FEMA restructuring, cybersecurity, and the department's reconciliation funding request. Members split sharply along party lines, with Republicans praising record-low border crossings and Democrats pressing on due process, appropriated-funds spending, and FEMA cuts. Begins at0:03:34

Who spoke

Chairman (Rep. Mark Amodei, R-NV)0:03:34: Opened the hearing, asked members to keep discussion civil and focused on appropriations0:04:05, and closed by asking for better communication from DHS going forward, requesting responses to questions for the record within 15 business days2:38:36.

Rep. Lauren Underwood (D-IL), Ranking Member0:04:28: Said the skinny budget is "filled more with politics than facts"0:05:17 and accused the administration of slashing cyber defenses, wasting money on detention, and deporting US citizen children0:05:450:06:27; later pressed Noem on due process, calling her answer a "no" when she wouldn't give a direct response0:26:14, and questioned Secret Service costs for the Army's June 14 parade designated a national special security event0:27:36 and a $500 million cut to CISA0:31:15.

Rep. Tom Cole (R-OK), Chairman, Full Committee0:11:20: Praised Noem's effectiveness and the "historic turnaround" at the border0:13:06; asked about FEMA reform, brick grants, and flooding in Oklahoma0:13:52.

Secretary Kristi Noem, DHS0:15:41: Said daily border encounters are down 93% since Trump took office, with March seeing under 7,200 encounters, the lowest in recorded history0:16:26; cited fentanyl trafficking down 54%0:17:21, six cartels designated foreign terrorist organizations0:17:21, Real ID enforcement beginning May 70:31:23, and said DHS needs 50,000–60,000 additional detention beds2:23:53.

Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-TX)0:33:35: Detailed border infrastructure needs in Laredo — river roads, carrizo cane removal, only one-third of cameras working, aerostat technology, and checkpoint upgrades0:33:550:35:511:50:14; also raised concerns about a proposed Social Security retirement-age change affecting Border Patrol agents0:37:46.

Rep. John Rutherford (R-FL)0:38:38: Praised expansion of the 287(g) program to 300+ new agencies0:39:20 and cited Operation Title Wave's 1,120 arrests in Florida, 63% with prior criminal convictions0:39:46; asked about "recalcitrant countries" refusing deportee returns0:42:38.

Rep. Ed Case (D-HI)0:44:51: Argued DHS is "overfunding" messaging while shortchanging cybersecurity, disaster mitigation, and TSA, and hiding a claimed 65% budget increase inside reconciliation rather than the base budget0:46:08; criticized proposed CISA (20%) and Coast Guard funding structure0:48:200:48:34.

Rep. Dan Newhouse (R-WA)0:51:23: Asked about agricultural labor programs (H-2A/H-2B) and Trump's proposed "touchback" plan for undocumented workers0:52:08, and about harbor maintenance tax evasion via Canada/Mexico0:56:11.

Rep. Veronica Escobar (D-TX)0:58:06: Pressed Noem with yes/no questions on accountability0:58:41, the deportation of US citizen children including one with cancer1:00:28, and use of ICE forms 71-078 and 71-176 for parents with US citizen children1:01:00; in a second round, raised a CBP union office relocation dispute in El Paso2:00:05 and an NBC/KFOR story on a mistaken ICE raid on a US citizen family2:02:25.

Rep. Juan Ciscomani (R-AZ)1:03:23: Asked about roughly 65,000 "gotaways" in the Tucson sector and technology investments for rough terrain1:04:20; later asked about legal immigration pathways and workforce visa programs2:07:09.

Rep. Tony Gonzales (R-TX)1:09:56: Asked about reimbursing Texas for border spending1:10:25 and cited a prior ICE letter showing 662,566 noncitizens with criminal histories on ICE's national docket as of July 20241:12:20; in round two praised the Office of Immigration Detention Ombudsman's downsizing and Stonegarden funding2:12:412:14:34.

Rep. Michael Guest (R-MS)1:15:26: Cited March 2025 southwest border encounters (11,201) versus prior years (189,000–222,000)1:15:56; asked about border wall construction progress (77.8 miles installed)1:17:56 and Mississippi tornado disaster assistance1:19:12; in round two asked about DHS Centers of Excellence funding, including Mississippi State's program2:25:07.

Rep. Ashley Hinson (R-IA)1:21:01: Criticized the Biden-era $4.7 billion southwest border contingency fund and the Shelter and Services Program, citing the Roosevelt Hotel in New York City as an example of misuse1:22:261:23:14; in round two asked about vetting of nationals from adversarial countries including China2:27:48.

Rep. Rosa DeLauro (D-CT), Ranking Member, Full Committee1:32:57: Challenged Noem on FEMA cuts, asking for evidence of "waste, fraud, and abuse" behind the cancellation of the BRIC program and $646 million in FEMA grant cuts1:33:531:36:01; in round two criticized a roughly $200 million DHS ad campaign featuring Noem, questioning the contracting process2:15:32.

Rep. Juan Ciscomani round-two and Rep. Newhouse round-two questions (see above) — combined into single bullets above per FirstBranch style.

Key moments

Noem said border encounters fell 93% since Trump took office, with March 2025 recording under 7,200 encounters — the lowest in recorded history — compared to over 15,000 a day at times under the previous administration0:16:260:16:52.

Sharp due-process exchange: Underwood repeatedly asked Noem whether the Constitution guarantees due process to everyone in America; Noem would not give a direct yes/no answer, prompting Underwood to say "I'll take that as a no"0:25:440:26:14.

Noem confirmed no US citizens have been deported but did not directly answer whether reconciliation funds could be used for the deportation of US citizens, a policy idea Trump raised publicly0:59:271:00:28.

Case argued DHS's claimed 65% budget increase is entirely loaded into the reconciliation bill rather than the base FY2026 request, calling it a "budget gimmick" to disguise the true funding ask, including $21 billion for the Coast Guard0:46:080:47:37.

DeLauro and Noem clashed over FEMA: Noem said Trump wants to eliminate FEMA as it exists and cited unpaid Hurricane Katrina claims as evidence of failure1:36:401:37:05; DeLauro demanded documented evidence of "dysfunction" and said there is no legal authority to withhold appropriated BRIC funds1:36:012:20:23.

DeLauro said DHS awarded $11.6 million to "People Who Think" and $35.5 million to "Safe American Media" for a border security ad campaign totaling roughly $200 million, funded partly by redirecting CBP and USCIS appropriations, and cited a Trump quote wanting Noem to "thank me for closing the border" in the ads2:16:302:17:29.

Gonzalez cited a prior ICE letter reporting 662,566 noncitizens with criminal histories on ICE's national docket as of July 2024, and Noem said the true number is likely higher1:12:201:12:59.

Noem said DHS needs an additional 50,000–60,000 detention beds to sustain current enforcement operations without slowing removals2:23:53.

Noem said violence against ICE officers is up over 300%, which she attributed to rhetoric from sanctuary-city leaders1:55:03.

Noem said CBP has collected over $32 billion in tariffs since April 2, and that 21 separate enforcement actions on tariffs have been taken since Trump took office1:59:130:57:21.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Appropriations Subcommittee on Department of Homeland Security
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2025-05-06
TypeHearing
Witnesses
The Honorable Kristi Noem — Secretary, U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Videoyoutube
Transcript361 caption blocks · 27,896 words · 2:39:36 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118192