Oversight Hearing – The United States Navy and Marine Corps

Defense Posture and Global ThreatsHouse Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense · 2025-05-14 · 119th Congress
The House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense held this oversight hearing to examine the Navy and Marine Corps' fiscal year 2026 posture, with a full budget request still unreleased. Begins at 0:14:44
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Navy and Marine Corps posture: shipbuilding delays, readiness, and munitions

Purpose

The House Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense held this oversight hearing to examine the Navy and Marine Corps' fiscal year 2026 posture, with a full budget request still unreleased. Members pressed Secretary of the Navy John Phelan, Acting Chief of Naval Operations Admiral James Kilby, and Marine Corps Commandant General Eric Smith on submarine and shipbuilding delays, fleet readiness, munitions stockpiles, workforce cuts, and next-generation fighter procurement. Begins at0:14:44

Who spoke

Chairman Ken Calvert (R-CA)0:14:44: Opened by citing an 18-24 month delay in the Columbia-class submarine0:16:54, a Virginia-class build rate stuck at 1.2 subs/year versus a needed 2/year0:17:19, and concerns about amphibious fleet readiness against the 31-ship requirement0:18:42; also pressed on sixth-generation fighter procurement urgency0:20:41.

Ranking Member Betty McCollum (D-MN)0:24:25: Welcomed the witnesses, criticized the slow FY26 budget rollout0:25:19, raised concern about ~16,000 planned civilian workforce cuts affecting public shipyards0:27:56, and later pressed for updates on Arctic readiness and Virginia-class production timelines1:08:07.

Chairman Tom Cole (R-OK), full committee chair0:29:23: Cited the Trump administration's ship-building executive order and goal of a 381-ship Navy0:31:31, asked about the Takamo nuclear communications mission possibly shifting to the Air Force1:01:27, munitions stockpiling for a near-peer conflict1:04:15, and Force Design 2030 progress1:06:44.

Ranking Member Rosa DeLauro (D-CT), full committee ranking member0:35:06: Asked about the CH-53K helicopter program0:36:23, warned of losing 16,000 civilian Navy workers0:36:54, and criticized "culture war debates" being injected into the defense funding process0:37:44.

Secretary of the Navy John Phelan0:38:13: Outlined priorities of shipbuilding, warfighter culture, and quality of life0:39:12; described visiting eight shipyards and finding Japanese welders spend zero time on paperwork versus 30-40% for U.S. welders0:52:34; said the Navy has 56,000 acquisition personnel handling 217,000 contracts0:59:36; detailed the restructured Virginia-class contract shifting to a more fixed-price model1:24:35.

Admiral James Kilby, Acting Chief of Naval Operations0:43:41: Cited 23,200 at-sea gaps being reduced by FY260:45:32, 40,000 sailors recruited last year (most since 2003)0:46:00, an 80% combat-surge-ready goal by January 20270:46:29; described SM-6 production ramping from 125 to 300 rounds/year and restarting the Mark 48 torpedo line1:05:20; discussed the HELIOS laser and cheaper counter-drone munitions like Coyote and Hellfire Longbow1:46:04.

General Eric Smith, Commandant of the Marine Corps0:47:24: Listed top priorities as restoring a 3.0 Amphibious Ready Group presence0:47:48, accelerating Force Design0:48:13, and improving quality of life via Barracks 20300:48:41; said amphibious readiness is at roughly 40% against an 80% target1:38:40; discussed JLTV cost impacts from the Army's program cancellation1:14:05.

Rep. Robert Aderholt (R-AL)0:54:51: Asked about Homeland Security border support roles and pressed on why the U.S. can't deliver shipbuilding on time and budget compared to Japan and Korea0:55:19.

Rep. Hal Rogers (R-KY)1:16:27: Highlighted Littoral Combat Ship successes in drug interdiction, including a $106 million cocaine seizure by USS Gabrielle Giffords1:17:24 and a Minneapolis-St. Paul LCS stopping two smuggling operations within 72 hours1:17:42.

Rep. (unspecified member speaking on LCS repurposing)1:22:04: Noted the committee had repeatedly requested reports on repurposing LCS ships and found past Navy responses inadequate1:22:32.

A committee member (ranking-member-adjacent, Virginia-class contract questioning)1:23:29: Pressed Phelan on how the shift from cost-plus to fixed-price contracting will control costs and speed production1:24:08.

Rep. (member raising force-structure oversight)1:29:57: Asked Phelan to commit to notifying the committee of any Navy/Marine Corps force-structure changes similar to Army restructuring1:30:26.

Rep. Robert Aderholt or another member (six-gen fighter/AI)1:32:26: Asked about mitigating risk in the sixth-generation fighter timeline given a 2027 window for potential China-Taiwan conflict1:32:48.

Rep. (Casease/Kai similar)1:38:10: Pressed General Smith on amphibious ship readiness rates and their effect on deployment risk1:38:40.

A committee member (international allies/mil-to-mil questioning)1:40:10: Asked Phelan about expanding military-to-military relationships with allies given reduced U.S. soft-power outreach1:40:53.

Rep. (Judge Carter, energy/nuclear focus)1:45:38: Asked about directed-energy weapons like HELIOS1:45:47 and pushed for faster development of the nuclear sea-launched cruise missile (SLCM-N)2:18:00.

Rep. (Diaz-Balart, Florida)2:22:25: Asked whether sixth-generation fighter delays would leave carriers without adequate aircraft2:22:52, and separately raised an unresolved $453 million FY25 appropriation not yet under contract2:25:35.

Rep. (Valadao)2:29:47: Asked about combat search-and-rescue gaps in the Pacific2:29:47, the Eisenhower carrier strike group's ~800 missiles fired at ~$1 billion cost against Houthi threats2:30:15, Marine Corps AI decision-making safeguards2:31:35, Operation Cattle Drive IT modernization2:33:03, and Marine attack drone team fielding pace2:33:58.

Rep. (Lee)1:51:13: Asked about the Fallon training range modernization1:51:13 and compensation for displaced grazing permit holders near Fallon1:52:09.

Rep. (Elie)1:56:30: Advocated strongly for the Navy's F/A-XX sixth-generation fighter and AIM-174B long-range missile, warning a three-year delay is a "de facto cancellation"1:57:24; asked about LSM gap mitigation using LCU 2000s and leased stern landing vessels1:59:48.

Rep. (Captor)2:01:06: Highlighted Great Lakes shipbuilding and industrial capacity2:01:30, and asked about Truman carrier incidents including F/A-18 losses in the Red Sea2:04:11.

Key moments

Columbia-class submarine now faces an 18-24 month delivery delay; Phelan attributed it to first-of-class inexperience, supply chain issues, and outdated shipyard practices0:50:430:51:10.

Phelan compared Japanese shipyard productivity — one 8-hour shift matching U.S. output over three shifts — partly because Japanese welders spend zero time on paperwork versus 30-40% for U.S. welders0:52:04.

Phelan disclosed the Navy has 55,833 acquisition personnel (27,031 in engineering/technical management) handling 217,000 contracts, calling the ratio "off"0:59:362:15:26.

Virginia-class submarine contract restructured from cost-plus (130% ceiling) to a fixed-price model with an 86% fixed cost and 138% ceiling to incentivize faster performance1:25:27.

Kilby said Navy amphibious readiness sits around 40% against an 80% target, calling for either increased readiness or more ships1:38:40.

Kilby detailed munitions ramp-up: SM-6 production rising from 125 to 300 rounds/year, and the Mark 48 torpedo line restarted after stopping in 1996, now producing 10/month1:05:201:05:51.

Rep. Elie warned that delaying the F/A-XX sixth-gen fighter three years amounts to a "de facto cancellation" and "a win for China"1:57:24.

Diaz-Balart pressed on an unresolved $453 million FY25 appropriation the Navy has not put under contract, amid reports OSD wants $500 million pulled from reconciliation2:25:352:26:00.

McCollum criticized the Army's unilateral decision to end the Joint Light Tactical Vehicle program without consulting the Marine Corps, calling it "beyond disappointing"0:27:27; Smith confirmed per-unit costs will rise as a result1:14:33.

Kilby disclosed the Eisenhower carrier strike group fired nearly 800 missiles at a cost of about $1 billion during Red Sea operations against Houthi threats, and described cheaper alternatives like Coyote missiles and high-velocity projectiles being tested2:30:152:31:10.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Appropriations Subcommittee on Defense
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2025-05-14
TypeHearing
Witnesses
General Eric Smith — Commandant, United States Marine Corps
The Honorable John Phelan — Secretary, United States Navy
Admiral James Kilby — Acting Chief of Naval Operations, United States Navy
Videoyoutube
Transcript327 caption blocks · 23,809 words · 2:38:24 runtime
EventCongress.gov 118229