Sharia-Free America: Why Political Islam & Sharia Law are Incompatible with the U.S. Constitution: Part II

Immigration Enforcement and Sanctuary PoliciesHouse Judiciary Subcommittee on Constitution and Limited Government · 2026-05-13 · 119th Congress
The House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government held this hearing — the second on this topic in 2026 — to examine claims that "political Islam" and Sharia law threaten the U.S. Begins at 0:17:14
Transcript
Highlights

Title

House hearing on political Islam and Sharia law compatibility with the Constitution

Purpose

The House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Constitution and Limited Government held this hearing — the second on this topic in 2026 — to examine claims that "political Islam" and Sharia law threaten the U.S. Constitution, focusing heavily on alleged examples in Texas, including a Wylie, Texas high school incident and the proposed "Epic City" development. Republican members and three witnesses argued Sharia-influenced institutions and immigration pose a growing domestic threat, while Democratic members and a fourth witness countered that the hearing was an election-season exercise in anti-Muslim fear-mongering with no evidence of any effort to impose religious law on non-adherents. Begins at0:17:14

Who spoke

Chairman Chip Roy (R-TX)0:17:14: Opened by describing Sharia and "political Islam" as an existential threat, citing Quran verses and Muslim Brotherhood figures0:18:150:20:34; cited CAIR's unindicted co-conspirator status in the Holy Land Foundation case0:21:04; later questioned Blair and Mekelburg on Texas immigration and Islamic institutions and closed by quoting the 1991 Muslim Brotherhood memorandum2:14:052:21:03.

Ranking Member Mary Gay Scanlon (D-PA)0:28:13: Called the hearing a distraction from Texas Republican primary politics with no supporting evidence0:28:130:29:21; noted the Trump DOJ closed a fair-housing investigation into the disputed Dallas-area development0:31:06; later entered a CBS article showing Wylie ISD disciplined staff over the "Why Islam" booth2:03:08 and questioned Tyler on the dangers of religious fear-mongering2:05:50.

Chairman Jim Jordan (R-OH), full committee chair0:35:33: Called the Southern Poverty Law Center a "scam" that paid a source over a million dollars and previewed a full-committee hearing on SPLC the following week0:35:55.

Ranking Member Jamie Raskin (D-MD), full committee0:36:46: Argued only 4 of 535 members of Congress are Muslim, making imposition of Sharia law implausible0:38:18; read the actual First Amendment text as already covering the hearing's stated concern0:39:54; cited the Fifth Circuit's Ten Commandments school-display ruling and Timothy McVeigh as a Christian-extremist parallel0:42:380:45:37; later pressed Blair on whether ordinary criminal law (not special religious laws) already covers murder and honor killings1:16:57 and sparred with Hunter Lopez over the Constitution's silence on God1:18:27.

Ammon Blair, Texas Public Policy Foundation0:48:27: Argued no religious system has constitutional license to operate parallel legal authority0:49:25; cited Gov. Abbott's designation of the Muslim Brotherhood and CAIR as terrorist/criminal organizations0:53:11; said Border Patrol released roughly 600,000 unvetted individuals under Biden-era policy per a Rep. Gonzales FOIA finding1:13:14.

Marco Hunter Lopez, Wylie East High School student1:00:04: Testified his Republican Student Club was denied recognition while the Muslim Student Association was approved1:00:29; described a February 2 "Why Islam" booth distributing Sharia pamphlets and conversion cards with administrators present1:01:56; said his school library stocks a Quran but no Bible1:47:03 and that he received death threats the school dismissed1:49:17.

Amy Mekelburg, RAIR Foundation USA0:53:53: Said she lives under armed security after threats tied to her activism and described the killing of activist Salwan Momika0:54:21; claimed roughly 8,000 Islamic nonprofits operate in the U.S., including 650 in Texas0:56:21; alleged Sharia-based tribunals and fatwa-issuing bodies operate inside insular American Muslim communities1:23:291:24:00.

Amanda Tyler, Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty1:05:25: Argued the Establishment Clause bars government from singling out any religion1:07:22; cited an Islamophobia index finding nearly half of Muslim K-12 families report their child was bullied for religious identity1:09:12; in later exchanges maintained secular criminal law, not special legislation, already addresses any criminal conduct1:35:41 and warned broad-brush targeting "makes everyone less safe and less free"2:06:022:20:05.

A committee member from North Carolina1:10:42: Cited a 2025 Washington state alleged honor-killing case1:11:11 and questioned Blair and Mekelburg on border security's link to the spread of political Islam and ISIS radicalization1:12:421:14:40.

A committee member from Wyoming1:21:34: Described a Dallas-area Sharia tribunal's own marketing claims about superseding U.S. courts1:22:05; questioned Mekelburg on coercion into Sharia tribunals and lack of oversight compared to U.S. courts1:23:121:25:07.

Rep. Steve Cohen (D-TN)1:27:10: Said Sharia tribunals operate on voluntary jurisdiction, not coercion1:27:34; pivoted to argue Texas redistricting and voting-rights rollbacks pose a far greater threat than Sharia, citing the Shelby and Alabama redistricting decisions1:29:291:31:14.

Rep. Rader (R-MO)1:33:03: Pressed Tyler on whether she defends religious-liberty claims by Deobandi, Salafi, and other Islamist sects tied to Texas mosques1:33:321:34:00; argued tolerating "beachheads of radical Islam" risks European-style outcomes1:36:38.

A committee member from Washington state1:38:45: Argued the hearing distracts from gas prices, health care costs, and the Iran conflict's $29 billion cost1:39:151:39:39; had Tyler confirm no U.S. legislation has ever proposed adopting Sharia law and no polling ranks it as a top concern1:41:501:42:16.

Rep. Gohmert (R-TX)1:45:05: Had Hunter Lopez detail the club-approval double standard1:45:33, the school's promotion of World Hijab Day1:46:20, and specific death threats he received1:49:18.

A committee member from California1:50:22: Called the hearing "religious bigotry" ahead of an election1:50:50; listed other oversight priorities including the Epstein files and a proposed $1 billion White House ballroom1:52:05; entered several UC exhibits on Christian nationalism and white supremacy1:55:32.

Rep. Hurd (R-TX)1:57:23: Argued assimilation to American values matters and accused Democrats of a double standard favoring Islamic over Christian materials in schools1:59:202:00:16; described his own background as a descendant of an enslaved ancestor representing a majority-white Texas district2:02:06.

A committee member from Wisconsin2:08:33: Cited a book on October 7 reactions in the U.S. and pressed Mekelburg on whether mainstream Muslim groups have condemned Hamas2:09:45; Mekelburg said she was unaware of any such condemnation2:11:152:12:18.

Key moments

Chairman Roy read Surah 47:4 and Muslim Brotherhood founder Sayyid Qutb's writings to argue Sharia is a governing legal system rather than private belief0:18:150:20:11.

Marco Hunter Lopez testified his Republican Student Club was denied recognition despite meeting all requirements, while the Muslim Student Association was approved without issue, and that a "Why Islam" booth distributed Sharia pamphlets and conversion cards at his school unchallenged1:00:291:01:56.

Raskin read the actual First Amendment text aloud and argued it already resolves the hearing's stated concern, calling the exercise "a complete waste of time"0:39:540:44:07.

Raskin got Blair to agree that existing secular criminal law — not a special religious statute — already covers murder, honor killings, and violence regardless of the perpetrator's religion1:16:571:17:27.

Rep. Rader pressed Tyler repeatedly on whether she defends religious liberty for Deobandi, Salafi, Khomeinist, and Muslim Brotherhood-linked groups; Tyler said she was unfamiliar with the specific sects and reiterated that criminal law, not religious status, governs conduct1:33:241:35:41.

Mekelburg estimated roughly 8,000 Islamic nonprofits operate nationwide, including about 650 in Texas, and described Sharia-based tribunals and fatwa-issuing councils operating without court oversight inside insular communities0:56:211:24:00.

Scanlon entered a CBS News article showing Wylie ISD investigated the "Why Islam" booth incident and disciplined staff for not following school procedures, countering claims of official complicity2:03:08.

Tyler cited a National Islamophobia Index finding Muslims are the religious group most likely to report discrimination, with nearly half of Muslim K-12 families reporting their child was bullied for religious identity1:08:481:09:42.

Jordan pivoted from the hearing topic to call the Southern Poverty Law Center a "scam" that paid a source over a million dollars, previewing a full-committee hearing on SPLC the following week0:35:330:35:55.

The Wisconsin member asked whether any mainstream Muslim organization has condemned Hamas over October 7; Mekelburg said she was aware of none, while Tyler said she had not researched the question but noted Muslim Americans frequently disclaim extremist violence2:11:152:12:39.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Judiciary Subcommittee on Constitution and Limited Government
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2026-05-13
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Mr. Ammon Blair — Senior Fellow, Texas Public Policy Foundation
Mr. Marco Hunter-Lopez
Ms. Amy Mekelburg — Founder & Editor-in-Chief, RAIR Foundation USA
Ms. Amanda Tyler — Executive Director, Baptist Joint Committee for Religious Liberty
Videoyoutube
Transcript460 caption blocks · 20,613 words · 2:21:32 runtime
EventCongress.gov 119267