The Southern Poverty Law Center: Manufacturing Hate

DOJ and Judicial Nomination VotesHouse Judiciary · 2026-05-20 · 119th Congress
The House Judiciary Committee held this hearing to examine a federal indictment alleging the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) defrauded donors by secretly paying roughly $3 million to informants tied to extremist groups, including the 2017 Charlottesville "Unite the Right" rally. Begins at 0:19:36
Transcript
Highlights

Title

House Judiciary examines fraud indictment against the Southern Poverty Law Center

Purpose

The House Judiciary Committee held this hearing to examine a federal indictment alleging the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) defrauded donors by secretly paying roughly $3 million to informants tied to extremist groups, including the 2017 Charlottesville "Unite the Right" rally. Republicans framed the case as evidence SPLC "manufactured hate" to fundraise and unfairly labeled conservative and Christian groups as hate groups, while Democrats countered that the prosecution is a politically motivated act of weaponization by the Trump DOJ, noting no donor has come forward alleging fraud. Four witnesses testified: two critical of SPLC (Tyler O'Neil, Tony Perkins, Dr. Carol Swain) and one defending it (Maya Wiley). Begins at0:19:36

Who spoke

Chairman Jim Jordan (R-OH)0:19:36: Opened by detailing SPLC "field source" payments totaling $3 million, including $270,000 to a Charlottesville organizer0:20:04 and $1 million over nine years to another informant0:20:31; said SPLC's income nearly tripled after Charlottesville, from $51 million to $133 million0:24:03, and credited the Trump DOJ/FBI for prosecuting the group0:24:57.

Ranking Member Jerry Nadler (D-NY)0:25:53: Asked why no donors or civil fraud suits have emerged if SPLC defrauded them0:26:230:28:38; argued the real fraud is Trump's roughly $1.8 billion DOJ/IRS "settlement" slush fund benefiting pardoned Jan. 6 defendants0:38:36; moved to subpoena Todd Blanche, Stanley Woodward, Scott Bessent, Frank Bisignano, and Brian Morrissey over the fund0:39:42, a motion later tabled by an 18–17 recorded vote5:14:215:26:32.

Dr. Carol Swain, former Vanderbilt/Princeton professor0:42:33: Said SPLC labeled her an "apologist for white supremacy" in 2009 after she criticized the group's "mission creep"0:44:170:45:06, contributing to career harm and her eventual 2017 retirement0:47:511:07:51.

Tony Perkins, Family Research Council0:47:51: Described the 2012 shooting at FRC headquarters by Floyd Corkins, who cited SPLC's hate map to find the building0:48:520:50:03; said the attack cost FRC over $6 million in security0:50:29 and that SPLC pressured banks/tech firms to "de-bank" conservative groups via the "Change the Terms" coalition0:51:300:52:23.

Tyler O'Neil, The Daily Signal0:53:52: Said SPLC's endowment totals $822 million0:54:22 and that his 2023 analysis found the hate map exaggerated hate by at least 267%0:55:42; cited the indictment's allegation that SPLC directed a Charlottesville organizer's postings and helped coordinate transportation0:56:40.

Maya Wiley, Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights0:59:01: Called the hearing part of a broader attack on civil rights groups0:59:32; said SPLC's informants helped prevent an Atomwaffen attack on a Las Vegas synagogue and gay bar2:07:45 and that SPLC's 2019 report to the FBI preceded the Charlottesville rally1:18:00; declined to state whether specific groups were "hate groups"1:20:54.

Rep. Barry Moore/gentleman from Arizona (R)1:06:53: Pressed Wiley on whether Dr. Swain was wrongly labeled1:06:53; cited SPLC's 2024 IRS filing showing the president/CEO's total compensation of $522,0001:08:48.

Rep. Nadler (further Q&A)1:12:44: Detailed the SPLC's $14 million judgment against the Daily Stormer founder for doxing a Jewish woman1:14:27 and its lawsuit against the Goyim Defense League over a 2024 Nashville "hate tour"1:15:10.

Rep. from Georgia (D), Hank Johnson-area questioning on field source 421:18:49: Asked O'Neil whether SPLC told donors it was paying the "extremist of the month" it featured on its website; O'Neil said no1:19:17.

Rep. from Georgia (D)1:24:33: Asked witnesses about Michael Donald, the 1981 lynching victim whose family's SPLC-backed lawsuit bankrupted the United Klans of America1:25:021:26:11.

Rep. Tom McClintock (R-CA)1:29:38: Compared SPLC to a "cause" that "becomes a racket"1:29:38; disputed Nadler's characterization of Trump's Charlottesville remarks, prompting a "words taken down" dispute1:31:461:32:20; asked Swain and Perkins why they never sued SPLC1:39:16.

Rep. Raskin (further Q&A)1:41:30: Rejected McClintock's characterization, restated Trump's "very fine people" quote1:41:30; noted right-wing groups such as the NRA and Heritage Foundation pay executives comparably or more than SPLC1:44:35.

Rep. from Virginia (R)1:46:55: Asked O'Neil about SPLC's ties to the Biden DOJ Civil Rights Division and its "hate map" being given to DOJ before publication1:49:16; discussed the Richmond FBI "radical traditional Catholics" memo sourced from SPLC1:50:53.

Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA)1:52:05: Noted DOJ moved to vacate Proud Boys/Oath Keepers convictions a week before indicting SPLC1:52:34; asked Wiley whether SPLC's tracking of these groups explains the prosecution1:54:41.

Rep. Harris/gentleman from North Carolina (R)1:58:46: Played video of shooter Floyd Corkins confessing he found FRC via SPLC's website2:00:34; asked Perkins about continued FRC listing on the hate map2:02:15.

Rep. from Pennsylvania (D)2:04:01: Argued SPLC's informant program helped stop real violence, citing the Atomwaffen and Navy Yard cases2:08:07.

Rep. Van Drew (R-NJ)2:43:26: Invoked Machiavelli, argued SPLC was weaponized for Democratic political goals and cited FBI targeting of Catholics and Hindus based partly on SPLC information2:45:36.

Rep. from South Carolina (R), Fry4:19:13: Argued SPLC's "$3 million investment" in informants effectively "doubled" fundraising after Charlottesville4:19:42; said SPLC "strayed" from its original poor-people's-law mission4:21:52.

Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-TX)4:25:02: Pressed all witnesses on whether Proud Boys and neo-Nazis are white supremacists4:25:31; argued the $1.8 billion Trump settlement fund effectively rewards white-supremacist-linked Jan. 6 defendants4:28:10.

Rep. from North Carolina (R)4:31:25: Questioned Wiley about the Charles Morrell attack in Boston and local "defund the police" policies4:32:144:32:42.

Rep. Moskowitz (D-FL)4:37:24: Pressed Dr. Swain and other witnesses to agree neo-Nazis are supremacists4:37:43; described rising antisemitic threats against himself and warned about hate's normalization4:41:384:42:39.

Rep. from Missouri (R)4:44:52: Asked O'Neil about NGOs' use of dark-money intermediaries and SPLC's hate-map criteria4:46:464:47:41.

Rep. from Wisconsin (R), Grothman4:50:11: Asked O'Neil to explain SPLC's history and the hate map's contents, and Perkins about alleged debanking of conservative groups4:51:044:54:05.

Rep. from New York (D), Goldman-area questioning4:55:20: Argued the fraud indictment is legally deficient because DOJ knew SPLC shared informant intelligence with the FBI, citing Acting AG Todd Blanche's contradictory Fox News statements4:56:474:57:41.

Rep. from Texas (R)5:01:26: Questioned Wiley on her past "defund the police" statements and a 2024 LinkedIn post referencing a "black job"5:02:145:03:30.

Rep. from Washington (R)5:07:49: Asked O'Neil how SPLC shifted from opposing groups like Aryan Nations to targeting groups like Moms for Liberty5:09:15.

Key moments

Jordan said SPLC paid Charlottesville "field source 37" to help coordinate transportation and attend the rally where Heather Heyer was killed, and that the organization's income nearly tripled afterward, from $51 million to $133 million0:20:040:24:03.

Nadler challenged the premise of the fraud case directly: "Where are all the donors complaining about having been defrauded? Where are the civil lawsuits?" — contrasting it with the 8,000-plaintiff Trump University fraud settlement of $25 million0:26:230:28:38.

Perkins testified that shooter Floyd Corkins, who wounded security guard Leo Johnson at FRC headquarters in 2012, told investigators he found FRC through SPLC's hate map0:50:03; Corkins' recorded confession was played in the hearing room2:00:34.

O'Neil said his 2023 analysis found SPLC's hate map exaggerated hate by at least 267%, including groups he said barely exist, like a Confederate memorabilia shop and a convent0:55:42.

Under questioning from a Georgia member, O'Neil confirmed SPLC did not tell donors it was paying "field source 42," whom it separately featured on its site as an "extremist" to solicit donations against1:18:491:19:17.

Rep. from New York cited Acting AG Todd Blanche's own contradictory public statements — first denying, then admitting five days later — that DOJ knew SPLC shared informant intelligence with the FBI, arguing this undermines the fraud theory4:56:474:57:41.

Wiley testified SPLC informant intelligence helped thwart a planned Atomwaffen Division attack on a synagogue and LGBTQ bar in Las Vegas and helped block a neo-Nazi's national security clearance2:07:454:03:09.

Crockett got Perkins and O'Neil, but not Wiley or Swain, to explicitly agree that Proud Boys and neo-Nazis are white supremacists, calling it a struggle to "agree on a simple set of facts"4:25:314:27:13.

Lofgren noted DOJ moved to vacate Proud Boys and Oath Keepers seditious-conspiracy convictions on April 14, one week before indicting SPLC on April 211:52:051:52:34.

The committee voted 18–17 to table Nadler's motion to subpoena Todd Blanche, Stanley Woodward, Scott Bessent, Frank Bisignano, and Brian Morrissey over the roughly $1.8 billion DOJ/IRS settlement fund5:14:215:26:32.

Metadata

CommitteeHouse Judiciary
Chamber / CongressHouse · 119th Congress
Date2026-05-20
TypeHearing
Witnesses
Mr. Tyler O'Neil — Author and Senior Editor, The Daily Signal
Mr. Tony Perkins — President, Family Research Council
Dr. Carol Swain — Author and Commentator, Former Professor at Vanderbilt University
Ms. Maya Wiley — President and CEO, The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights
Videoyoutube
Transcript609 caption blocks · 34,540 words · 5:26:51 runtime
EventCongress.gov 119311