AIConfirmation hearing for Air Force Secretary and three Pentagon nominees

Defense Posture and Global ThreatsSenate Armed Services · 2025-03-27 · 119th Congress
The Senate Armed Services Committee met to consider the nominations of Dr. Begins at 0:14:51
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Confirmation hearing for Air Force Secretary and three Pentagon nominees

Purpose

The Senate Armed Services Committee met to consider the nominations of Dr. Troy Meink to be Secretary of the Air Force, Michael Duffey to be Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment, Emil Michael to be Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering, and Keith Bass to be Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs. Sen. Deb Fischer presided in place of Chairman Wicker, who arrived later; members questioned the nominees on nuclear modernization, acquisition reform, space programs, military health care, and the recent Signal chat controversy. Begins at0:14:51

Who spoke

Sen. Deb Fischer (R-NE), presiding0:14:51: Opened the hearing in the chairman's absence, introduced the nominees and their families0:14:51, and administered the committee's standard conflict-of-interest and cooperation questions to all four nominees0:44:40.

Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI), Ranking Member0:16:33: Outlined each nominee's portfolio and challenges — Air Force readiness and modernization for Meink0:17:00, acquisition reform for Duffey0:17:53, tech modernization for Michael0:19:08, and military health system modernization for Bass0:20:33; later pressed Michael on reversing dismissals of skilled acquisition and lab personnel0:55:23.

Sen. Mike Rounds (R-SD)0:21:47: Introduced Dr. Meink, citing his South Dakota roots, engineering background, and senior Air Force/NRO roles0:21:470:23:36.

Rep. Scott Fitzgerald (R-WI)0:24:06: Introduced Michael Duffey, citing his Wisconsin ties and experience serving two presidents and seven defense secretaries0:24:06.

Dr. Troy Meink, nominee for Secretary of the Air Force0:25:26: Described 35 years of Air Force service including 100+ Gulf War missions0:27:11 and 16 clean financial audits at his current organization0:29:43; later said the fighter and bomber fleets are "probably too small"1:24:18 and that the F-15 cannot operate in the highest-threat environments1:22:53.

Michael Duffey, nominee for Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment0:30:35: Pledged to accelerate lethality delivery and strengthen the defense industrial base0:33:43; said media reports of an 8% DoD budget cut are inaccurate, describing instead a reallocation review1:06:57; confirmed he was not part of the Signal chat and would follow department procedure if the IG investigates1:59:241:59:39.

Emil Michael, nominee for Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering0:34:58: Cited his Uber and Pentagon (Secretary Gates-era) background0:37:41; emphasized leveraging private-sector AI investment and honoring lab talent to retain engineers0:55:521:18:13; endorsed onshoring supply chains and using AI to manage shipbuilding bottlenecks2:13:12.

Keith Bass, nominee for Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs0:41:04: Described 20 years in the Navy and V.A. medical center leadership0:42:33; rejected the premise he dismissed anomalous health incident (AHI) reports at the CIA, saying he worked to streamline victims' access to Walter Reed care1:04:51; committed to onshoring pharmaceutical manufacturing1:42:32 and prioritizing mental health access1:14:51.

Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR)0:57:33: Pressed on ensuring nuclear modernization funding doesn't crowd out the Air Force's conventional budget0:58:07; raised the ~1,800 fighter-pilot shortfall0:59:26; asked Bass to review MHS Genesis recruiting-screening problems1:02:22.

Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)1:03:33: Questioned Bass on directed-energy attack victim care at Walter Reed1:03:33; asked all three other nominees to square resource requests with Secretary Hegseth's proposed 8% budget cut1:06:39.

Sen. Kevin Cramer (R-ND)1:09:10: Questioned the Air Force's Tranche 2/3 transport-layer sole-source approach potentially excluding small bidders1:09:47; pressed Bass on TRICARE mental-health accreditation barriers linked to two airmen suicides1:13:37.

Sen. Angus King (I-ME)1:15:02: Argued technology wins wars and pressed on hypersonics/directed energy funding, small-business acquisition access, university research, and blast-overpressure brain health1:15:351:18:55.

Sen. Ted Budd (R-NC)1:21:19: Asked about Seymour Johnson's deployable combat wing concept1:21:19 and whether the F-15 is ill-suited to today's threat environment1:22:24.

Chairman Roger Wicker (R-MS)0:53:17: Pressed Meink on Cape Canaveral launch constraints and space-launch privatization0:53:17; noted this was the committee's first hearing since the Signal chat/Yemen strike controversy1:29:15; closed the first round on OTA and middle-tier acquisition authority2:24:46.

Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-HI)1:28:24: Asked standard misconduct-disclosure questions of all four nominees1:28:24; entered the Atlantic Signal-chat article into the record1:30:18; pressed Meink on Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam construction delays and a 30-year infrastructure plan1:31:151:33:17.

Sen. Jim Banks (R-IN)1:34:33: Asked Meink about Air National Guard priorities and Grissom Air Reserve Base's aging KC-135 tankers1:34:331:37:59.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)1:39:56: Cited a Nov. 2023 Defense Logistics Agency finding that one-third of essential drugs face high-risk supply chains tied to China1:40:47; noted DoD paid roughly $100 billion to resume adenovirus vaccine production after a decade without a commercial manufacturer1:43:071:43:33; secured Bass's commitment to onshore drug production1:43:54.

Sen. Tommy Tuberville (R-AL)1:45:15: Asked Duffey about high-energy laser progress after visiting Huntsville1:45:15; asked Michael and Meink about retaining engineers against private-sector competition1:47:07; asked Bass about growing referrals away from military treatment facilities1:49:22.

Sen. Elissa Slotkin (D-MI)1:56:32: Pressed Meink on a fighter-mission replacement for Selfridge's retiring A-10s1:57:28; questioned Duffey on Signal chat awareness and any other unsecured operationally sensitive communications, receiving a "no"1:59:482:00:28.

Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS): Not heard speaking in this transcript.

Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO): Not heard speaking in this transcript.

Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL): Not heard speaking in this transcript.

Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO)2:02:29: Dismissed the Signal-chat criticism as "faux outrage"2:02:29; touted the F-47/NGAD contract going to Boeing in St. Louis2:03:01; asked Meink about commercial space imagery providers tied to NGA West2:05:45.

Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ)2:08:28: A former Navy pilot, said the Signal chat exposed critical operational details — launch times, aircraft types, weapons, time on target — that endangered pilots even if not a full "war plan"2:09:112:09:41; questioned Duffey and Michael on the U.S. shipbuilding industrial base and the SHIPS for America Act2:10:47.

Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK)2:13:56: Described Russian bomber and joint Russian-Chinese naval/bomber incursions near Alaska2:15:10; pressed Meink for a "110%" commitment on delayed F-35 basing in Alaska after a decade of promises2:17:102:18:00; sought commitment on North Com/INDOPACOM-requested infrastructure2:18:56.

Sen. Gary Peters (D-MI)2:19:23: Sought commitment to honor Selfridge's KC-46 tanker basing and pursue a future fighter mission there2:19:52; asked Michael about spreading defense R&D investment beyond Silicon Valley/Massachusetts2:25:48; closed the hearing, noting QFRs due within two business days2:28:30.

Key moments

Sen. Hirono entered into the record the Atlantic article detailing the Signal chat with strike plans for Yemen and called for an investigation1:30:181:30:53.

Sen. Kelly, a former carrier-strike pilot, said the Signal chat contained some of the government's "most critical information" — launch times, aircraft types (F/A-18s, Q-9s), weapons (Tomahawks), and time on target — which he said put pilots at "great risk" even though it wasn't a full war plan2:09:112:09:41.

Sen. Schmitt called the Signal-chat scrutiny "faux outrage" tied to "the election loss" rather than genuine national security concern2:03:01.

Duffey said he was not part of the Signal chat, was unaware of any other unsecured chats with operationally sensitive or classified information, and would follow department procedure if the Inspector General investigates1:59:241:59:392:00:37.

Duffey disputed media reports of an 8% DoD budget cut, calling it instead a directive to reallocate a prior administration's budget toward new priorities1:06:57.

Sen. Warren cited that DoD spends $5 billion annually on prescriptions, that a third of essential medicines face high-risk foreign (often Chinese) supply chains, and that DoD ultimately paid roughly $100 billion to restart adenovirus vaccine production after a decade-long commercial manufacturing gap that coincided with service-member deaths1:40:471:41:141:43:33.

Sen. Cramer said two airmen who sought mental health care died by suicide after being denied treatment under TRICARE's accreditation rules, prompting NDAA language requiring review after 12 months of access failures1:13:371:14:04.

Sen. Sullivan demanded a "110%" commitment on long-delayed F-35 basing in Alaska, noting the Air Force had been promising the move for roughly 10 years2:17:102:17:34.

Meink said the Air Force's fighter and bomber fleets are "probably too small" and that F-15s cannot operate in the highest-threat environments, though they retain value today1:24:181:23:25.

Michael described using AI-style "dashboard" visibility into supply chains, similar to sophisticated private manufacturers, to eliminate shipbuilding bottlenecks2:12:37.

Metadata

Official titleHearings to examine the nominations of Troy Meink, of Virginia, to be Secretary of the Air Force, Michael Duffey, of Virginia, to be Under Secretary for Acquisition and Sustainment, Emil Michael, of Florida, to be Under Secretary for Research and Engineering, and Keith Bass, of Texas, to be an Assistant Secretary, all of the Department of Defense.
CommitteeSenate Armed Services
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
Date2025-03-27
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript394 caption blocks · 15,476 words · 2:29:00 runtime
EventCongress.gov 336762