AIConfirmation hearing for Air Force and Defense policy nominees

Defense Posture and Global ThreatsSenate Armed Services · 2025-05-01 · 119th Congress
The Senate Armed Services Committee convened this hearing to consider three Department of Defense nominations: Matthew Lohmeier to be Under Secretary of the Air Force, Justin Overbaugh to be Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence and Security, and Daniel Zimmerman to be Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs. Begins at 0:24:51
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Confirmation hearing for Air Force and Defense policy nominees

Purpose

The Senate Armed Services Committee convened this hearing to consider three Department of Defense nominations: Matthew Lohmeier to be Under Secretary of the Air Force, Justin Overbaugh to be Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence and Security, and Daniel Zimmerman to be Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs. Much of the hearing focused on Lohmeier's past public statements on politics in the military and January 6, alongside standard policy questions on NATO burden-sharing, basing decisions, and intelligence reform for the other nominees. Begins at0:24:51

Who spoke

Chair Roger Wicker (R-MS)0:24:51: Opened by welcoming the nominees' families, praised Lohmeier's anti-D.E.I. advocacy0:25:20, and introduced Overbaugh and Zimmerman's roles0:26:200:27:15; later ran standard committee questions0:49:09 and pressed all three on reconciliation bill funding commitments0:50:38 and basing law compliance0:54:47.

Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI), Ranking Member0:28:08: Said Lohmeier's "extreme partisanship" and 2021 book *Irresistible Revolution* are "disqualifying"0:28:580:29:30, pressed him on a 2024 post about "serious consequences" for senior leaders0:56:40, and later cited a threatening email sent to civil/military personnel2:20:02.

Sen. Bill Hagerty (R-TN)0:34:02: Introduced Daniel Zimmerman as his former Senate staffer, citing his CIA and White House work on the Abraham Accords0:35:06.

Matthew Lohmeier, nominee for Under Secretary of the Air Force0:36:38: Described his Air Force/Space Force career, including commanding an $18 billion missile-warning architecture0:39:54, and pledged to eliminate politics from basing decisions0:55:58; repeatedly defended his book and social media statements as private-citizen speech0:57:451:33:29, denied using the word "hoax" for January 61:22:33, and said he does not believe the Ukraine crisis is entirely "the West's fault"1:56:51.

Justin Overbaugh, nominee for Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence and Security0:41:48: Cited 25 years of intelligence/security experience including tactical deployments to Afghanistan and Iraq0:43:21; committed to working with the DNI's office1:05:28 and to telling policymakers unwelcome intelligence truths2:06:51.

Daniel Zimmerman, nominee for Assistant Secretary of Defense for International Security Affairs0:45:40: Outlined priorities on NATO, Russia/Ukraine, and the Middle East0:46:33; committed to filling the vacant Deputy Assistant Secretary for NATO position0:53:58 and supported the administration's strikes on the Houthis while noting he lacks classified access to assess their efficacy1:59:07.

Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR)1:02:31: Pressed Overbaugh on defense intelligence agency governance and last year's NDAA-mandated review1:03:53, and asked Lohmeier to commit to increasing Air Force resources and fixing pilot retention1:06:191:06:40.

Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH)1:08:19: Criticized Secretary Hegseth's move to end Women, Peace and Security implementation, noting a Joint Staff memo said China and Russia have "no equivalent" of WPS1:10:28, and asked all three nominees whether they need such tools1:11:281:12:381:12:59.

Sen. Mike Rounds (R-SD)1:13:21: Asked Overbaugh about coordinating cyber, space, and AI threats1:13:40 and Zimmerman about two-theater conflict planning1:16:33; also asked Lohmeier about increasing B-21 Raider numbers1:18:08.

Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-HI)1:18:56: Asked all nominees a standard fitness-to-serve question on sexual misconduct1:18:56; accused Lohmeier of spreading "divisive, harmful views" and January 6 conspiracy theories1:19:53, and pressed him to recuse himself from personnel actions involving Gen. Whiting, Gen. Pepper, and Col. Fran1:23:18.

Sen. Joni Ernst (R-IA)1:25:12: Pressed Lohmeier for a firm commitment to fund the Sioux City, Iowa Air National Guard runway upgrade promised 22 years ago1:26:121:27:58, calling his hedged answer "disappointing"1:28:47.

Sen. Tim Kaine (D-VA)1:31:14: Read multiple Lohmeier social-media posts calling "the left" liars and "the real oppressor"1:31:431:32:10, and pressed repeatedly on his "government-led false flag and hoax" comment about January 61:32:381:32:59.

Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-AK)1:37:23: Highlighted Russian and Chinese military incursions near Alaska over 2.5 years1:38:12 and asked Lohmeier to commit to Alaska basing infrastructure and four promised KC-135 tankers1:40:531:42:24.

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT)1:42:55: Questioned Lohmeier's managerial qualifications, noting his largest command was ~100 people versus 700,000 he'd oversee if confirmed1:44:331:44:56, and got his commitment not to use Signal to discuss sensitive Air Force missions1:49:02.

Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL)1:49:11: Asked Zimmerman about foreign military sales delays frustrating allies in Denmark, Finland, and Estonia1:49:39, and questioned whether the U.S. pays for weapons development while allies later own the IP1:51:31.

Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ)1:53:05: Repeatedly asked Lohmeier whether Russia was "justified" in invading Ukraine, citing his posted article "Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West's Fault"1:53:351:56:51.

Sen. Tommy Tuberville (R-AL)1:58:34: Asked Zimmerman to assess U.S. operations against the Houthis, citing 27 targets struck as of April 271:58:34, and asked Overbaugh about the Missile and Space Intelligence Center in Huntsville1:59:34; challenged Lohmeier on lacking large-budget management experience2:01:02.

Sen. Angus King (I-ME)2:03:01: Pressed Lohmeier on managing the Sentinel nuclear modernization program, comparing the job to being "general manager" rather than "centerfielder"2:03:58, and asked Overbaugh to commit to telling unwelcome truths, citing intelligence failures on Afghan and Ukrainian "will to fight"2:07:272:07:57.

Sen. Ted Budd (R-NC)2:09:17: Asked Lohmeier about F-15 pilot training capacity strain at Seymour Johnson Air Force Base following the Selfridge (Michigan) F-35 basing decision, citing a 50% jump in required training sorties by FY2027-282:10:312:11:13.

Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL)2:13:48: Pressed Lohmeier on why he did not file an Article 138 complaint or use protected whistleblower channels under Title X Section 1034 before writing his book2:14:552:16:56, arguing he was relieved of command "not for your beliefs but for how you chose to express them"2:18:08.

Vice Chair Patty Murray (D-WA)2:24:29: Briefly recognized Lohmeier's request to respond during the Reed exchange2:24:29.

Key moments

Sen. Reed called Lohmeier's writings and podcast appearances, made while on active duty in command, "disqualifying" for the Under Secretary role0:28:58.

Lohmeier confirmed he was relieved of his squadron command after about one year — versus a standard longer term — for publishing his book while on active duty1:45:081:45:19.

Sen. Hirono asked directly whether Lohmeier believes January 6 was a "government-led false flag operation"; he denied using the word "hoax" but said he believes undercover government agents were present at the Capitol1:21:381:22:08.

Sen. Kaine read Lohmeier tweets calling "the left" liars and "the real oppressor" and pressed him on the "false flag hoax of the Capitol" phrase; Lohmeier said he did not recall writing that specific phrase1:32:381:33:57.

Sen. Blumenthal contrasted Lohmeier's largest command (about 100 people, one year) with the ~700,000 personnel he would oversee if confirmed, comparing the situation to Secretary Hegseth's prior managerial record1:44:331:45:34.

Sen. Kelly repeatedly asked whether Russia was "justified" in invading Ukraine, citing a Lohmeier-shared article titled "Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West's Fault"; Lohmeier said the framing was "far too simplistic" and did not answer yes or no1:54:271:56:51.

Sen. Ernst said Lohmeier's answer on the Sioux City, Iowa runway upgrade — pending 22 years — was "disappointing" after he gave a firmer commitment on Sen. Cotton's Arkansas base priority1:27:151:28:47.

Sen. Shaheen cited a leaked Joint Staff memo stating China and Russia have "no equivalent" of the Women, Peace and Security program and that combatant commands recommended keeping it, contradicting Secretary Hegseth's move to end it1:10:28.

Sen. Duckworth asked whether Lohmeier considered filing a protected whistleblower complaint (Title X, Section 1034) or an Article 138 complaint before writing his book; he said he could not recall the circumstances2:14:552:17:04.

Sen. Reed introduced into the exchange a threatening email sent to DoD personnel referencing "corrupt traitorous officers" who would be removed over D.E.I. policies, asking Lohmeier what he would do if he learned of such messages2:20:022:20:54.

Metadata

Official titleHearings to examine the nominations of Matthew Lohmeier, of Arizona, to be Under Secretary of the Air Force, Justin Overbaugh, of Florida, to be a Deputy Under Secretary, and Daniel Zimmerman, of North Carolina, to be an Assistant Secretary, all of the Department of Defense.
CommitteeSenate Armed Services
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
Date2025-05-01
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript404 caption blocks · 14,552 words · 2:26:06 runtime
EventCongress.gov 336896