Hearings to examine how the Trump Administration is addressing the human cost of soft on crime policies

Immigration Enforcement and Sanctuary PoliciesSenate Judiciary · 2025-09-30 · 119th Congress
The Senate Judiciary Committee held this hearing, titled "Blue City Chaos and Tragedy," to examine violent crime trends in Democratic-led cities and highlight the Trump administration's deployment of federal law enforcement and National Guard troops to Washington, D.C. Begins at 0:19:56
Transcript
Highlights

Title

Senate hearing frames "blue city" crime as test of Trump crime policies

Purpose

The Senate Judiciary Committee held this hearing, titled "Blue City Chaos and Tragedy," to examine violent crime trends in Democratic-led cities and highlight the Trump administration's deployment of federal law enforcement and National Guard troops to Washington, D.C. and other cities. Chairman Grassley framed the hearing around reductions in D.C. crime following federal intervention, while Ranking Member Durbin and other Democrats objected to the hearing's premise and instead pointed to funding cuts, mass-deportation resource diversion, and comparative crime statistics between red and blue states. Two panels testified: crime victims, a police union head, a state senator, a gun-violence survivor/advocate, and a retired general, followed by federal law enforcement officials from the U.S. Marshals Service and DEA. Begins at0:19:56

Who spoke

Chair Chuck Grassley (R-IA)0:19:56: Opened by citing a 53% reduction in D.C. murders and 75% reduction in carjackings since federal intervention0:20:22, criticized "soft on crime" prosecutors and sanctuary policies0:23:16, and later questioned witnesses on crime-data manipulation and the D.C. crime lab's lost accreditation1:08:043:03:09.

Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL), Ranking Member0:28:16: Objected to the hearing's political framing, noted Illinois has had lower murder rates than Missouri, Louisiana, and Alabama for two decades0:29:49, and said Trump cut $160 million in community safety funding and $72 billion for state/local law enforcement0:32:06; later questioned Pemberton on January 6 pardons0:28:161:14:55 and Jackson and Pemberton on ATF funding cuts1:18:25.

Mrs. Forlesia Cook, D.C. resident and grandmother of a murder victim0:41:33: Testified her grandson Marty was shot seven times and killed in 2017, and his killer received roughly 16 years served concurrently with other charges0:43:33; said she now feels safer under the Trump administration's D.C. intervention0:46:05.

Maj. Gen. William Enyart, retired Illinois National Guard commander0:47:48: Argued the Guard is not trained for police work and estimated the Los Angeles deployment cost $120 million for 4,000 guardsmen over 60 days0:50:20; warned of eroding trust between soldiers, families, and employers0:51:53.

Det. Gregg Pemberton, D.C. police union head0:53:07: Said MPD has fallen from about 3,800 to under 3,200 officers since 2020 with over 800 vacancies0:53:52, alleged command staff manipulated crime data to undercount felonies1:09:16, and supported repealing D.C.'s 2022 police reform law via the Clean D.C. Act0:55:43.

Gregory Jackson, Rocket Foundation/Community Justice Action Fund, gun violence survivor0:56:41: Described being shot in 2013 and treated as a suspect before receiving care0:57:10, said the Trump administration cut $1 billion in mental health resources and $812 million in violence-intervention funding1:00:16, and repeatedly declined to disown past organizational statements about defunding police under questioning from Sen. Schmitt and Sen. Hawley1:34:392:17:59.

Tennessee State Sen. Brent Taylor1:02:05: Said Memphis reported 111,000 crimes and 19,000 arrests last year, with 56% of arrests dismissed1:02:37, criticized Shelby County DA Steve Mulroy's policies1:04:33, and touted Operation Viper's 500 arrests and 100 federal indictments1:06:26.

Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX)1:20:51: Questioned Pemberton on drug trafficking's role in gang violence and links to the southern border1:21:09, and pressed on whether "defund the police" rhetoric contributed to attacks on ICE officers1:22:26.

Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT)1:24:53: Criticized $500 million in cuts to community violence-intervention grants, including $2 million each from the Alliance of Formerly Incarcerated Men and Circle of Brotherhood1:26:24; later pressed Marshals and DEA officials on whether their agencies' resources had been cut3:23:16.

Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), presiding1:30:47: Entered a staff report on DOJ grants to the Soros-backed Vera Institute1:31:19, and questioned Sen. Taylor on Memphis cargo theft and the Cargo Security Innovation Act1:47:13.

Sen. Eric Schmitt (R-MO)1:32:01: Read past statements from Jackson's organization calling to "divest" from policing and questioned Jackson on whether the group still supports defunding police1:33:46.

Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ)1:37:23: Called the hearing's "Blue City Chaos" framing a "farce," citing that states voting for Trump have had murder rates 33-50% higher than states voting for Harris/Biden over the past two decades1:39:14.

Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-TN) questioning1:42:33: (see above)

Sen. Katie Britt (R-AL)1:54:53: Said Birmingham and Montgomery, both long run by Democratic mayors, account for 40% of Alabama's crime despite being a small share of its population1:55:17; asked Pemberton about the impact of D.C.'s 2022 police reform law1:59:35.

Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA)2:01:10: Countered that Republican-led states have had murder rates 50% higher than Democratic-led states for decades, citing a 27% homicide drop in Los Angeles from community-based strategies2:02:40, and noted Congress cut ATF funding by $400 million2:03:07.

Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX)2:06:54: Cited Washington D.C. murders nearly tripling from 2012 to 20232:07:24, named individual D.C. crime victims2:07:56, and had Pemberton confirm the Clean D.C. Act would permanently reduce crime2:11:43.

Sen. Josh Hawley (R-MO)2:14:33: Pressed Jackson on a "Policymakers Playbook" report from his organization advocating defunding police and investing in "two spirit" community programs, which Jackson said he could not fully explain2:16:362:18:59.

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)2:20:42: Cited FBI data showing Alaska, Tennessee, Arkansas, Louisiana, Missouri, and Kansas all had worse 2024 violent crime rates than Illinois2:20:42, and described Rhode Island's community-policing results, including a 73% drop in total violent crime since 19902:23:04; later pressed U.S. Marshal Marketos on investigating conspiracies to threaten federal judges, including the "pizza-doxxing" of judges3:17:023:29:56.

Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC)2:26:36: Said pardoned January 6 defendants convicted of assaulting police should still be imprisoned2:26:36, and pressed Taylor and Jackson on holding local elected officials accountable rather than relying on federal bailouts2:29:31.

Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-HI)2:33:13: Objected to characterizations that Democrats want to "defund the police," cited $800 million in DOJ public safety grant cancellations2:34:46, and questioned Enyart on Guard readiness impacts2:35:47.

Sen. Peter Welch (D-VT)2:38:53: Said Vermont spends more per capita on policing than Iowa, South Carolina, Texas, Utah, and Alabama despite lower crime2:40:53, and raised mental health and homelessness as drivers of the criminal justice system2:42:40.

Chris Marketos, U.S. Marshals Service2:50:00: Reported a 39% drop in D.C. violent crime and 75% drop in carjackings since Operation "Making D.C. Safe and Beautiful" began August 7, with 3,496 arrests2:52:16; acknowledged under Sen. Durbin's questioning that roughly 200 of ~4,000 Marshals personnel (about 5%) were diverted to immigration enforcement3:06:09.

Vasilios "Bill" Goumenis, DEA Washington Division2:55:57: Reported robbery down almost 50%, carjackings down 80%, and violent crime down nearly 40% in D.C. since the surge began2:58:13, described a case where a suspect with an armed-robbery record was released before Marshals could serve a federal warrant3:02:11, and said about 20 of his roughly 150 special agents (about 10-13%) were diverted to support immigration enforcement3:07:31.

Sen. Ashley Moody (R-FL)3:11:16: Asked Goumenis whether drug traffickers here illegally could be prioritized for deportation and thanked witnesses for law enforcement service3:11:45.

Sen. Chris Coons (D-DE)2:28:49: Cited Reuters reporting that federal drug prosecutions are at their lowest in decades and money-laundering charges dropped 24% this year3:33:09, and pressed Goumenis on how much DEA manpower was diverted to D.C. street patrols3:34:08.

Key moments

Chairman Grassley cited a 53% reduction in D.C. murders, 57% reduction in robberies, and 75% reduction in carjackings since federal intervention began0:20:22.

Pemberton testified that D.C. crime data was manipulated, with management directing officers to downgrade felonies to misdemeanors, and disputed the accuracy of the reported 35% 2024 crime decrease1:09:161:10:33.

Sen. Booker and Sen. Whitehouse both presented FBI/state data showing several Republican-led states and cities (Louisiana, Tennessee, Missouri, Mississippi, Alabama) have higher murder and gun-homicide rates than Illinois or Chicago1:39:142:20:42.

Sen. Hawley confronted Gregory Jackson with his organization's "Policymakers Playbook," which called for defunding police and funding "two spirit" community programs; Jackson said he was "not completely aware" of the report's language2:16:362:19:31.

Mrs. Cook testified her grandson was shot eight times and his body dumped, taking her family nine months and their own investigation to find his remains and identify the case, before his killer received roughly 10 years in prison1:58:13.

Marketos reported a 39% drop in D.C. violent crime and 3,496 arrests since Operation "Making D.C. Safe and Beautiful" began August 7, while acknowledging under Sen. Durbin's questioning that about 5% of Marshals personnel were diverted to immigration enforcement2:52:163:06:09.

Sen. Durbin cited reporting that federal drug prosecutions dropped roughly 10% and money-laundering charges 24% this year, attributing the decline to resources shifted toward immigration enforcement, while noting 70% of those detained by DHS have no criminal record3:08:270:34:00.

Sen. Whitehouse pressed Marketos repeatedly on whether the Marshals Service investigates conspiracies to threaten federal judges, including a wave of "pizza-doxxing" incidents referencing a murdered judge's son, without receiving a direct answer [2:19:39 corrected below]3:20:403:30:17.

Sen. Britt noted Birmingham and Montgomery, both long governed by Democratic mayors, account for roughly 40% of Alabama's crime despite a small population share, challenging Durbin's statewide comparison1:55:17.

Goumenis described a case in which a suspect arrested with a stolen firearm and drugs during the D.C. surge was released by D.C. Superior Court before a federal warrant could be served3:02:11.

Metadata

CommitteeSenate Judiciary
Chamber / CongressSenate · 119th Congress
Date2025-09-30
TypeMeeting
Witnesses
(none listed in event metadata)
Videosenate-isvp
Transcript564 caption blocks · 25,746 words · 3:40:01 runtime
EventCongress.gov 337445